Who Is Liable for Trademark Infringement When Multiple Parties Are Involved in a Supply Chain?

Liable for Trademark Infringement When Multiple Parties

Trademark Infringement Liability can extend beyond the business whose name appears on a counterfeit or deceptively branded product. In a modern supply chain, manufacturers, brand owners, importers, distributors, wholesalers, retailers and online marketplaces may all play a role in bringing goods to consumers. However, their involvement does not make them automatically or equally liable. Under Indian law, liability depends on the specific conduct of each party, its authority to use the mark, its role in manufacturing or commercialising the goods, and the relevant statutory provisions. The Trade Marks Act, 1999 identifies several activities which may amount to trademark use, including applying a mark to packaging, offering goods for sale, importing products and using a mark in advertising. The key issue is therefore not simply who owns or sells the goods. It is whether each party has engaged in an act of infringement or has otherwise incurred legal responsibility.

What does the Trade Marks Act say about supply chain liability?

Section 29 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 provides the main framework for infringement of registered trademarks. A person who is not the registered proprietor or a permitted user may infringe a registered mark by using an identical or deceptively similar mark in the course of trade, subject to the conditions in the relevant subsection.
Section 29(6) is particularly important in supply chain cases. It identifies several activities as use of a registered mark. These include applying the mark to goods or packaging, offering goods for sale, putting them on the market, stocking them for sale, importing or exporting them, and using the mark in business papers or advertising.
Section 29(7) addresses another important participant: a person who applies a registered mark to material intended for labelling, packaging or advertising, while knowing or having reason to believe the application is unauthorised. This provision can be relevant to packaging printers, label suppliers and other service providers. The statutory framework therefore examines the conduct of each participant. A business does not escape responsibility merely because another party owns the goods or arranged the transaction.

Who may be liable at different stages of the supply chain?

a) Manufacturer: Applying an unauthorised trademark

A manufacturer may face direct infringement liability when it applies another business’s registered trademark to goods without permission. This can happen when a factory produces counterfeit products, uses a similar brand name or manufactures additional stock beyond the scope of an authorised production agreement. A manufacturer may also breach a licensing or manufacturing agreement by using the brand for products, territories or customers outside the agreed arrangement. The contractual breach and trademark infringement are separate legal questions. The proprietor may pursue both where the facts support them.

b) Packaging and label suppliers: Knowingly facilitating unauthorised branding

A packaging printer or label supplier may become legally exposed if it knowingly applies a registered mark to labels, boxes, wrappers or promotional material without proper authorisation. Section 29(7) is relevant because it specifically addresses the knowledge or reason to believe element. A supplier who receives suspicious instructions, notices obvious inconsistencies in authorisation documents or continues producing infringing labels after receiving a credible warning may face greater risk. However, a supplier is not automatically liable merely because it provides ordinary printing services. The evidence of knowledge, the nature of the work and the circumstances of the transaction are important.

c) Importers: Bringing infringing goods into India

Importers may face direct exposure even if they did not manufacture or label the products. Section 29(6)(c) expressly includes importing and exporting goods under a registered mark. In Brown-Forman Distillery, Inc. v. Brewholik Private Limited & Anr., decided by the Delhi High Court on 2 April 2026, the dispute concerned whiskey imported into India under the mark OLD FORESTER. The importer relied on an agreement with a Nepalese manufacturer and sought permission to sell existing stock. The Court declined to permit the sale of the goods in the circumstances before it, considering the Indian registration and Section 29(6)(c).

The decision illustrates the risk faced by importers who rely only on an overseas supplier’s permission. A foreign manufacturer’s ownership or registration does not automatically establish authority to use the mark in India. Importers should examine Indian trademark registrations, territorial rights, consent and the applicability of statutory exceptions before placing goods on the Indian market. The exhaustion provisions under Section 30(3) and the conditions in Section 30(4) may also require consideration in genuine goods cases.

d) Distributors and wholesalers: Circulating infringing products

Distributors and wholesalers may incur liability where they offer, stock or circulate goods bearing an infringing mark. Their role is not merely administrative if they actively place the goods into commercial circulation. For example, a distributor who receives counterfeit products and supplies them to retailers may be engaging in activities covered by Section 29(6)(b). A wholesaler who advertises the goods under the disputed mark may also attract scrutiny under the same provision. The legal position may differ where a distributor deals in genuine goods lawfully placed on the market by the proprietor or with its consent. Section 30(3) recognises exhaustion in specified circumstances. However, it is not a blanket defence for counterfeit products or goods falling outside the statutory conditions.

e) Retailers: Offering or stocking infringing goods for sale

Retailers are often the final commercial link between the product and the consumer. A retailer may face infringement claims if it offers, displays or stocks goods for sale under an unauthorised mark. A retailer cannot necessarily avoid responsibility by saying it purchased the products from a wholesaler. The relevant question is whether its own conduct falls within Section 29 and whether a statutory defence is available. Retailers should maintain supplier invoices, purchase records, product authentication documents and correspondence. These records can help establish the source of the goods and the retailer’s due diligence. They do not automatically defeat an infringement claim, but they may be relevant to the dispute and the relief sought.

Can online marketplaces also be held liable?

Online marketplaces introduce a different legal question. A platform may simply host third party listings, or it may actively participate in advertising, promoting, selling or facilitating the supply of goods. The distinction matters because Section 79 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 provides conditional safe harbour protection to intermediaries for third party information.
In PUMA SE v. IndiaMART Intermesh Ltd., the Delhi High Court initially found, in January 2024, that the platform’s use of PUMA in its seller registration process and its handling of counterfeit listings raised infringement concerns. However, the Division Bench reconsidered the matter in IndiaMART Intermesh Ltd. v. PUMA SE, decided on 2 June 2025.
The appellate Court held that merely allowing sellers to identify products by brand name through a dropdown menu did not, by itself, establish infringement or aiding and abetting. It recognised the platform’s listing function and the conditional protection available under Section 79. However, the platform was required to make reasonable efforts to prevent infringing listings and take action when counterfeit listings were brought to its notice. Allowing sellers to relist the same infringing products after removal could also undermine the due diligence requirement. This decision is important because it avoids two extremes. An online marketplace is not automatically liable for every third party listing. Equally, it cannot disregard its statutory responsibilities when it becomes aware of specific infringement or actively participates in unlawful activity.

Are all parties in a supply chain jointly liable?

No. Indian trademark law does not make every business in a supply chain automatically or equally liable merely because it handled the same product. Each party’s conduct must be examined against the requirements of the relevant legal provision. A manufacturer may directly apply an infringing mark. An importer may bring the goods into India. A retailer may offer them for sale. An intermediary may lose safe harbour protection if the statutory conditions are not met. These are different forms of potential responsibility.
The Delhi High Court’s decision in Lifestyle Equities CV v. Amazon Technologies Inc. (2025) is also relevant to the assessment of connected businesses. The Court examined the relationship between the brand owner, retailer and platform operator, including the level of control exercised over branding and distribution. It considered the extent to which closely connected entities could distance themselves from the infringing commercial activity. The case demonstrates why courts may examine the actual business arrangement rather than rely solely on the separate legal identities of companies. However, corporate affiliation alone does not establish infringement. Evidence of participation, control, licensing and the transaction structure remains important.

What remedies are available to trademark owners?

Section 135 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 allows courts to grant civil remedies in appropriate infringement and passing off proceedings. These may include injunctions, damages, an account of profits and delivery up of infringing labels and marks for destruction or erasure. A claimant may seek relief against more than one participant where the evidence supports a cause of action against each. The court may consider the role of each defendant, the nature of its conduct and the relief necessary to prevent continuing infringement.
Businesses facing supply chain trademark disputes should preserve purchase orders, manufacturing agreements, invoices, import documents, packaging samples, digital listings and communications. These records help establish where the infringing activity occurred and who was responsible for it.

How businesses can reduce supply chain trademark risks

Brand owners should conduct trademark searches, register their marks in relevant classes and document permissions granted to manufacturers, distributors and licensees. Contracts should specify permitted use, territories, product categories, quality control, packaging approval, subcontracting restrictions and termination obligations. Manufacturers and suppliers should verify the authority of customers who request branded production. Importers and distributors should check the Indian trademark position before accepting products. Retailers should maintain traceable procurement records and respond promptly to credible infringement notices. Online platforms should maintain accessible intellectual property complaint procedures, seller verification measures and processes for dealing with repeat infringers. These steps can help demonstrate compliance with applicable due diligence obligations.

Conclusion

Trademark infringement in a supply chain is not limited to the manufacturer or the business whose brand appears on the product. Importers, distributors, wholesalers, retailers, packaging suppliers and online platforms may also face legal consequences depending on their conduct. The decisive factor is each party’s involvement in the unauthorised use or commercialisation of the mark. A clear contractual structure, proper trademark checks and reliable transaction records can help businesses manage these risks before they develop into costly disputes.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Who is primarily liable for trademark infringement in a supply chain?

The party which directly uses an unauthorised mark may face infringement liability. This could be a manufacturer, importer, distributor or retailer, depending on the facts and the activity covered by Section 29 of the Trade Marks Act.

Can a distributor be held liable for selling counterfeit products?

Yes. Offering, stocking or putting infringing goods on the market may amount to trademark use under Section 29(6). A distributor’s liability depends on the circumstances and any applicable statutory defence.

Is a retailer liable if it unknowingly sells counterfeit goods?

A retailer may still face an infringement claim if its conduct falls within Section 29. However, evidence about the source of the goods, procurement practices and surrounding circumstances may be relevant to the case and the relief available.

Can an importer be sued for trademark infringement in India?

Yes. Section 29(6)(c) expressly includes importing goods under a registered mark. Importers should verify the Indian trademark position and the supplier’s authority before importing branded products.

Can packaging suppliers be held responsible for trademark infringement?

Yes, in appropriate circumstances. Section 29(7) addresses the unauthorised application of a registered mark to labelling, packaging and advertising material where the supplier knows or has reason to believe the application is unauthorised.

Are online marketplaces responsible for counterfeit products sold by third party sellers?

Not automatically. Section 79 of the Information Technology Act provides conditional safe harbour protection. The platform’s level of participation, due diligence and response to specific infringement complaints are relevant to determining whether the protection applies.

Can a trademark owner sue multiple parties in the same supply chain?

Yes, where there are legally sustainable claims against each party. The claimant must establish the relevant conduct and legal basis for relief against each defendant. Mere involvement in the same supply chain is not enough by itself.

What documents help establish liability in a supply chain trademark dispute?

Manufacturing agreements, trademark licences, purchase orders, invoices, import documents, packaging samples, product photographs, distribution agreements and communications can help establish the role and conduct of each participant.

Drop Us Your Enquiry

Cookie Consent with Real Cookie Banner